Malad West, Mumbai 400064
Consultation +91 97731 50167

EPFO or Private Trust
for Provident Fund
Which is better?

Choosing between the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) and a Private Trust for Provident Fund is important for companies in India. This guide gives a clear comparison of these options to assist businesses in making smart choices about provident fund management for their employees.

A Provident Fund Consultant  – plays a vital role in providing guidance for Private Trust for PF for your Company for EPFO is better.

Private Trust for Provident Fund or EPFO, which is better

Option 1: EPFO Registration

What is EPFO?

The Employees' Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) is an official body under the Ministry of Labour & Employment, created by the EPF & MP Act, 1952. It manages India’s biggest social security scheme, covering workers in the organized sector.

 

Key Benefits of EPFO Registration:

  • No Investment in Infrastructure: Companies don’t have to spend on infrastructure for fund management.
  • Government Security: Funds are protected by the government, providing safety for employees.
  • Standard Procedures: Consistent processes across different locations ease compliance.
  • Automated Compliance Check: EPFO has automated systems for monitoring compliance.
  • Less Administrative Work: Companies have less admin work than managing a private trust.
  • Single Portal for Transactions: One platform allows for all transactions.
  • No Need for Extra Staff: Current employees can handle EPF without hiring more staff.
  • Frequent Interest Updates: Employees get regular information about interest earned.
  • System for Complaints: There is an organized way to handle employee grievances.
image
PF Consultants - Kaizen Consultancy Services

Option 2: Private PF Trust for PF

What is a Private Trust for PF?

In accordance with the provisions of Section 17 of the EPF and MP Act, 1952, a Private PF Trust is formed which permits an organisation to handle its employees' provident funds in-house and in accordance with the guidelines issued by the EPFO.

Key Benefits of Private PF Trust:

  • Enhanced Proprietary Control Over the Management of Funds: Organisations can design specific strategies which best suit their requirements in the management of funds.
  • Higher Rates of Return on Investments: Unlike EPFO’s private trusts, Private trusts are able to invest in more yielding instruments.
  • More Efficient Claim Settlements: Claims are settled faster than through the EPFO.
  • Customized Policies for Employees: Trusts are able to design different policies suited for various categories of employees.
  • Employee Funds Managed Within the Organization: The organisation is able to deal directly with employees regarding the management of their funds.
  • Better Cash Flow Management: With better controls of cash flow, better plans are developed.
  • Improved Employee Views on Funds: Fund members are likely to get more satisfaction, as a result of improved funds management on a targeted basis.
  • Specialised Service: The services are determined according to the specific requirements of the organisation and the feedback from employees.
  • Operational Flexibility: Trusts are provided with enhanced operational flexibility, all within the limits of the law.
EPF Options

Making Your Choice: Private Trust for PF or EPFO?

Choose EPFO if:

  • Your employee count is less than 100.
  • You have limited administrative capacity.
  • Your operations are based at a single location.
  • You prefer standardized processes with minimal operational involvement.

Choose Private Trust if:

  • Your employee count exceeds 100.
  • You possess strong administrative capabilities.
  • You operate across multiple locations.
  • You require investment flexibility and faster claim processing.

Recent Notable Statistics

As per EPFO Annual Report 2022-23:

  • The EPFO has provided an average return of 8.15 percent.
  • Private trusts offer average returns of between 8.5 per cent and 9.5 per cent.
  • Claims with regard to EPFO can be expected to be settled in 20 days on an average while claims from Private Trusts take 3 to 7 days.
image
Provident Fund - Private Trust

Compliance Requirements Private Trust and EPFO

Each option has to observe certain compliance standards.

Common Requirements:

  • Monthly remittance of contributions
  • Lodging periodic returns
  • Maintaining employee records
  • Annual filing of compliance documents
  • Within the Company audits

Trust-Specific Additional Requirements:

  • Adherence to investment norms
  • Periodic Board of Trustees’ meetings
  • Inspections by EPFO
  • Any other reporting requirements

Legal Framework

The legal framework governing these options includes:

  • EPF Act. 1952.
  • EPF Scheme, 1952.
  • EPFO Guidelines on Exempted Establishments
  • Notifications on Investment Pattern
EPF Options

Key Court Judgments for PF Private Trust

Key Court Judgments

Regional PF Commissioner vs Hooghly Mills (2012)

This case established guidelines for trust formation and defined investment patterns, emphasizing the importance of compliance in managing private trusts.

Citation: (2012) 2 SCC 489 Source: https://main.sci.gov.in

 

EPFO vs Employees PF Trust, Garware Wall Ropes (2019)

This judgment clarified compliance requirements and set operational standards for private trusts, ensuring that they adhere strictly to regulations set by the EPFO.

Citation: WP No. 1273 of 2019 Source: https://bombayhighcourt.nic.in

Quick Connect

If you're an Employer in Mumbai and want to choose between Private Trust or EPFO or want a compliance with the Provident Fund compliance with Act in best possible way, contact the expert team of Kaizen Consultancy Services in Mumbai.
Call us at +91-977 31 50 167 to schedule a consultation and learn how we can assist your business.

Contact Us